Twitter user “卡卡喬喬 (@xdxderen7)” went immensely
viral after sharing a video in which he accuses the production team of the
second season of “Jujutsu
Kaisen” to “copy” a variety of scenes and animation styles from
different anime franchises such as “, ““, among many others. The
video consists of a collection of fragments showing a comparison with the
“supposed” original scene.One Punch Man“, “JoJo's Bizarre
AdventureTengen Toppa Gurren Laggan“, “One Piece
Copykaisen Anime Collection
— 卡卡喬喬 (@xdxderen7) December 26, 2023
パクリ廻戦 アニメ集
They mock all the anime fans
彼らはすべてのアニメファンをひどく傷つけた
Never forgive them
彼らを決して許さないでください
I can never forgive them for stealing my favorite animation
私は好きなアニメを盗んだことを決して許せない pic.twitter.com/eOqUNOYyJF
Of course, the user did not leave any comments out, since he
added: «A collection of scenes from “Copy-Kaisen”. The team makes fun of
all anime fans. They should never forgive them. I can't forgive them for
stealing my favorite scenes». He also mentioned his desire for this
video to reach more people, something that eventually ended up happening, since
it already has more than 3.4 million accumulated views.
There is certainly a lot of resentment on the part of the
user, especially when they have to respond to those who appear to defend the
production team and enter into debate. The main concept that is
discussed In these exchanges it is usually that of “tribute”, of which
generally few have an idea of the meaning. In fact, there is a fine
line between “copying” and “homaging,” and it is common for this line to be
placed at convenience.
If you are a fan of the series that is being attacked,
you will surely say that everything is a “tribute”; while if you don't care
about the series in question, then you will say that it is a
"copy". At the end of the day, there is no one neutral in
this matter, since the general public does not discuss these types of things.
Coming back to the main topic, whether the sequences shown from “Jujutsu Kaisen” are really copies or homages depends a lot on the conditions behind the production. It is possible that the same animators who worked on the original scenes were now working again on this series. Considering the evidence of the appalling working conditions at MAPPA, it would be understandable that these animators, faced with the pressure to finish quickly, choose to recycle their previous work.
MAPPA was quick to announce a third season of “Jujutsu
Kaisen,” and some even believe it could premiere in 2024. If the pressure
continues to build, will these types of events continue to occur? of incidents?
It's quite likely, and the internet community had something to say:
- «I
can't say for sure, but why do they make the copies so obvious? Wouldn't
it be appropriate to just copy enough so that no one notices?».
- «It
seems that it is difficult to come up with choreography for a fight, and
the animators simply recycle what they have done before».
- «Foreigners
often praise Jujutsu Kaisen as a work of art, and it makes sense
considering how much they copy from other successful anime».
- «There
is no doubt that the scene taken from live-action is a reference. MAPPA
probably doesn't give the animators enough time to think about the scenes
in their heads and draw them, and they just have to repeat what they've
done in the past.
- «If
the animator or the director were the same, it would not be a copy.
However, it is complicated to think that there were so many coincidences
and that they led to all these comparisons».
- «Producing
storyboards is an art in itself, it requires a lot of mental work and, of
course, enough time. Excuses like “tributes” are easy outs for the lazy
entertainer or, in this case, the exploited entertainer».
- «It
is a franchise that has been a copy of the manga, what did you expect?».
- «It
is totally different from Chainsaw Man, there the scenes were made from
scratch and were “true tributes”. Here I only see a dishonest copy».
- «It
is becoming a habit to trace and copy other scenes made by more recognized
projects, perhaps animators are losing their shame».
- «Well,
then Jujutsu Kaisen references and pays homage to many other titles. There
is nothing new in that statement. We could say the same about all the
copies that have been made within JoJo's Bizarre Adventure and One Piece,
right? ».
- «Shonen
animes do this kind of thing all the time».
- «I
have no problem with making some kind of tribute, but this is directly a
copy in design, timing and choreography, there are too many coincidences.
Really unfortunate».
- «They
are called “references”, something very common in any type of animation,
it is not copying or cheating. Even with the little production time
available, it is called “taking advantage of resources”».
- «These
are “references”, not “copies”, not “thefts” or anything like that. Learn
the difference and stop hating current series just because they become
popular. The animators put a lot of work and effort into this despite the
horrible conditions at MAPPA.”
Sauce: Yaraon!